When Overacting is a Good Thing

December 16, 2022 | Ilana Rapp
Photo Credit: Monkey Business Images / Shutterstock.com

When it comes to the world of acting, there’s a fine line between overacting and just plain bad acting.

Overacting is when an actor goes overboard with their performance, making it seem unnatural or forced. Bad acting, on the other hand, is simply bad acting. It’s when an actor gives a wooden or stilted performance that lacks any emotion or believable motivation.

In recent years there’s been an increase in the number of overacting performers in films, television and stage. This is largely due to the popularity of reality shows and the need for actors to be more expressive. These shows often require the participants to be very emotional in order to create drama for the viewers. As a result, many people have learned what they need to do in order to get noticed (Think about Mike “The Situation” Sorrentino from the show Jersey Shore).

On top of that, audiences have become more sophisticated. They’re now able to see through subtlety and appreciate performances that are more direct and honest.

Back in the day, overacting was often seen as a negative thing. But, when it’s done well, it can be advantageous — it can help to create a more interesting scene and it can also add humor. Plus, it may make the scene one of the only scenes you remember!

So what’s the real difference between overacting and bad acting? For one, overacting is usually done in an attempt to be dramatic or comedic, while bad acting is simply the result of poor technique. Additionally, overacting often makes a character more likable and relatable, while bad acting often makes a character seem flat and one-dimensional.

What’s the trick for an actor to know how to find that balance between overacting and bad acting? They know when to tone it down and when to turn it up. That’s what makes them great at their craft. Ultimately, of course, it’s up to the director to decide whether an actor is overacting or just plain bad.

Three tips to find the balance:

  1. 1. Know your character. This is crucial. If you know your character inside and out, you’ll be able to play them truthfully without going overboard.
  2.  

  3. 2. Do your research on the world they inhabit. This will help enhance your performance and prevent you from overacting or playing things too broadly.
  4.  

  5. 3. Trust your instincts. Once you’ve done your homework, trust your gut instinct when it comes to how to play a scene. Sometimes less is more, and if you feel like you are overdoing it, chances are you probably are.

 

Overacting has definitely evolved over the years. In the early days of film, overacting was often necessary due to the limitations of technology. Silent films, for example, required actors to exaggerate their expressions and movements in order to convey emotions and tell a story without any dialogue.

Nowadays, technology has come a long way and we don’t necessarily need actors to overact in order to understand what’s going on. In fact, many modern audiences find it distracting and even annoying. That’s why finding the balance is imperative.

That said, there are still some roles that require an actor to overact in order to be effective. For instance, if a character is supposed to be comically exaggerated, then the actor needs to commit to that in order for it to work. Point in case: character Peggy Bundy (played by Katey Sagal) in Married… with Children. She’s usually the over-the-top performer, but in THIS CLIP, it’s Marcy D’Arcy (played by Amanda Bearse) who has the reigns.

Below are some over-the-top, unforgettable acting moments from a long time ago.

With the exception of Vampire’s Kiss, which is a horror comedy, the other clips are not comedic. Yet somehow, the overacting completes the mood.

The Shining: Here’s Johnny – Jack Nicholson

Mommie Dearest: No Wire Hangars – Faye Dunaway

Vampire’s Kiss: Freaking Out – Nicolas Cage

The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 2: Aro’s Laugh – Michael Sheen

Maximum Overdrive: We Made You – Ellen McElduff

You decide whether the above is good overacting or bad acting.

Looking to get your big break? Sign up or login to Casting Networks and land your next acting role today!

Related articles:
Off-beat or Unconventional Acting Roles
3 Tips to Help Any Actor Improve Their On-Camera Performance
Getting Over Stage Fright: Advice for Actors