How To Find Your Acting Brand with ReelArc’s Steven C. Schmidt

If the word brand makes you want to close this tab, you’re not alone.

For many actors, branding feels like the opposite of creativity. It sounds limiting, overly corporate and at odds with the reason most people pursue acting in the first place. After all, isn’t the goal to play every kind of character—not define yourself as just one?

That’s exactly why Steven Schmidt wants to change the conversation.

The co-founder of ReelArc joined How We Roll host Robert Peterpaul to unpack one of the industry’s most misunderstood concepts. Drawing on years of helping actors develop demo reels and career strategy, Schmidt argues that branding isn’t about creating a persona or squeezing yourself into a box. It’s about understanding what people naturally remember about you and using that clarity to build trust with casting professionals.

As Schmidt puts it, your brand isn’t something you invent. It’s already there.

In this episode, you’ll learn:

Why “actor brand” doesn’t have to be a dirty word

How authenticity creates stronger auditions

What makes a demo reel memorable

Why consistency builds trust with casting

How your brand evolves as your career grows

Get access to thousands
of high-quality roles.

JOIN FREE TODAY

Your Brand Is Already Following You

“If I could get rid of the word brand, I would,” Schmidt admits early in the conversation.

The term comes with a lot of baggage. It can sound fake or manufactured, as if actors are expected to market a version of themselves instead of pursuing honest performances. But Schmidt offers a much simpler definition: your brand is the collection of ideas that come to mind when someone hears your name.

Whether it’s a casting director, an acting teacher or someone you’ve worked with once, people are constantly forming impressions based on the information available to them. In other words, your brand exists whether you’ve thought about it or not.

That’s why Schmidt encourages actors to stop thinking about branding as something they’re creating and start thinking about it as something they’re uncovering. The process isn’t about becoming someone else—it’s about recognizing the qualities people consistently respond to and learning how to communicate those qualities more clearly.

That clarity matters because the entertainment industry runs on trust. Casting directors make bets on actors. Producers make bets on casting directors. Audiences make bets every time they choose one movie or series over another. The easier you make it for people to understand what you bring to the table, the easier it becomes for them to picture you in their project.

Authenticity Beats Trying to Be Everything

Many actors begin their careers believing versatility means showing they can play absolutely anyone. Schmidt understands the instinct—he had it himself.

Looking back at his early years in New York, he remembers trying to keep every possibility open. He figured he’d change his haircut, appearance or style for whatever role came along. Then a casting director gave him advice that completely shifted his perspective: “We don’t see the possibilities. We see what is.”

That lesson became foundational.

Actors often prepare for auditions by asking what a doctor acts like, or how a lawyer should sound, or what a detective would do in a particular moment. Schmidt believes there’s a better question: What would you bring to that doctor, lawyer or detective?

“There are all different ways that your essence can be viewed through the lens of profession and relationship,” he explains.

That’s where memorable performances come from. Two actors can deliver the exact same lines, but the one who brings a genuine point of view gives casting something to hold onto. Instead of watching someone imitate a character type, they’re watching a real person filter the material through their own experiences, humor, vulnerability or edge.

As Schmidt reminds actors throughout the episode, your goal isn’t to erase yourself from the work. It’s to discover which parts of yourself tell stories best.

Finding Your Strengths Starts With Honest Questions

One of the biggest misconceptions about branding is that someone else can simply hand it to you.

Schmidt doesn’t believe that.

While he works closely with actors to identify patterns and strengths, he says the most important part of the process is ownership. If an actor doesn’t genuinely connect with the description, it becomes just another PDF they’ll never open again.

Instead, he asks questions designed to help actors recognize themselves.

What role do you naturally play in your friend group? What assumptions do people make about you when they first meet you? What qualities do people mention over and over again? When you’re excited, angry or heartbroken, how does that emotion show itself?

The answers often begin with familiar words like “funny” or “quirky,” but Schmidt doesn’t stop there. Funny how? Quirky in what way? What does that actually look like in your behavior?

Those follow-up questions are where the interesting discoveries happen.

For actors, that kind of self-awareness becomes incredibly useful in the audition room. Rather than trying to manufacture a personality for every role, you begin to understand the emotional patterns and perspectives you naturally bring into every performance.

A Great Demo Reel Shows Your Connective Tissue

As co-founder of ReelArc, Schmidt has spent years helping actors create custom demo reels, and he believes the strongest reels do much more than showcase good acting.

They reveal a clear throughline.

“A reel is on-brand when it shows the connective tissue about where you win your field across different tones and genres,” he says.

That doesn’t mean every scene should feel identical. A comedy scene and a dramatic scene can sit side by side as long as they both reveal something unmistakably you. Casting isn’t looking for proof that you can disappear into twenty unrelated characters in two minutes. They’re looking for evidence of a perspective that’s compelling enough to imagine in their project.

The same philosophy extends to headshots. Schmidt prefers simple, distraction-free images that allow the actor—not the wardrobe, props or styling—to become the focus. The goal isn’t to create a character before you’ve even entered the audition room. It’s to invite people to connect with the person behind the performance.

Throughout the conversation, Schmidt returns to one idea again and again: people remember specificity. The clearer your point of view becomes, the easier it is for casting professionals to remember you when the right opportunity comes along.

Your Career Will Evolve—But Your Perspective Stays With You

One fear actors often have is that defining themselves too early will limit future opportunities.

Schmidt sees it differently.

He points to actors like Aubrey Plaza, Harrison Ford and Viola Davis, whose careers have evolved dramatically over time while remaining unmistakably their own. The roles have changed. The genres have expanded. They’ve taken on more authority, complexity and range. Yet audiences still recognize the same underlying qualities that made them compelling in the first place.

Eventually, he says, your brand stops being a collection of descriptive words and simply becomes your reputation as an actor.

Until then, consistency isn’t about restriction. It’s about building trust.

By understanding what makes you memorable today, you create a stronger foundation for tomorrow’s opportunities. As your life experience grows, so will the kinds of stories you’re able to tell. The common thread is that audiences will continue recognizing the unique perspective that only you can bring.

Near the end of the conversation, Schmidt offers one final piece of advice that neatly ties everything together.

“Retain your spark of madness.”

It’s a reminder that the qualities actors sometimes try hardest to smooth over—their odd sense of humor, unconventional perspective, quiet intensity or unexpected vulnerability—are often the very things that make them unforgettable.

Branding, then, isn’t about sanding off your edges.

It’s about giving those uniquely human qualities room to shine.